Criteria for Evaluating MA Thesis Proposals- IO

Every I/O graduate student will be expected to submit an MA Thesis Proposal that contains the following sections:

  1. Introduction
  2. Method
  3. Analyses and Proposed Results
  4. Proposed Implications

All proposals will be reviewed against the following criteria.

Introduction

  • Comprehensively summarizes and references the relevant literature as it pertains to the thesis topic.
  • Critically points out the most relevant and important theories and empirical evidence to establish a clear purpose and contribution for the thesis.
  • Demonstrates an accurate and deep understanding of the research literature (the authors/ theorists would be in full agreement with their ideas or findings being summarized in this way).
  • Hypotheses are well substantiated and clearly follow from the literature review.

The proposal introduction is comprehensive, whereas the final version of the MA thesis should be of a length appropriate for a journal. That is, we intend for you have a manuscript ready to submit to a journal by the time you complete the Master’s thesis.

*Note* Because this requirement (that the final version of the MA thesis is in manuscript form) is unique to the I/O area, it may be necessary to inform any committee member who is outside of the I/O area about this requirement.

Method

  • Research design is clearly articulated and follows logically from the literature review.
  • The method allows for the optimal testing of the research hypotheses.
  • All relevant measures are described in detail and appropriate based on the subject matter of the thesis.
  • Drafts of all critical materials, as agreed upon by the committee, are included in the Method section or in an Appendix.

Analyses and Proposed Results

  • Proposed analyses are described in detail.
  • Predicted results are also presented (in tables or figures) to demonstrate a mastery of the underlying theory and proposed analyses.
  • Strengths and weaknesses of the research design and measurement are clearly articulated.

Proposed Implications

  • The implications, and importance, of the proposed findings for theory and practice are described in detail for the topic domain.

Organization, Clarity, and Format

  • Proposal is structured with a clear organization.
  • All aspects of the proposal are explored in a highly systematic and disciplined manner. 
  • Appropriate elements of style are consistently used throughout (e.g., transition sentences between paragraphs, appropriate headings).
  • Sentences are clear and concise.
  • There are no grammatical errors.
  • There is consistent and accurate use of APA style.